How Can Local Government Earn Trust in the Era of Fake News?

This entry was contributed by on September 26th, 2017 at 9:00 am and is filed under , , , .
Download PDF

Rebuilding trust in American democracy was a central theme among public communicators who gathered at the City-County Communicators and Marketing Association (3CMA) conference Sept. 6-8 in Anaheim, Calif.

#3CMAAnnual: “How can local government earn trust in the era of fake news?”

Explaining the “why” as part of a sustained story is a better strategy than regular blurt-outs to engage with the public, said Santa Monica City Manager Rick Cole in the opening conference session. Invest in the time to develop key messages. Think about the way people feel about their government. He urged local government communicators to define the WHY to stay relevant. “Our customers own us — and need to know not just what we do, but why.”

“This is a two-way street,” Cole said. “We can’t keep saying ‘Government has got this.’ We need to work together.”

Cole spoke about restoring pride in public service and fostering civil discourse. Intent on assisting a rebirth of citizen engagement and local democracy through these 3CMA attendees – public information officers, communications managers, videographers, multimedia producers and more – he went on. No powerpoint presentation.

Amazingly, he led the group of about 300 conference attendees in singing “America the Beautiful” in an emotional moment. Everyone rose to their feet in a burst of song. (View video here)

#3CMAAnnual: “As governments, we have an illusion as a monopoly that we will always exist.”

Another central session focused on “Navigating the Era of Alternative Facts: Restoring Trust and Trust in the Media and Government.” Apparently, trust is at an all-time low among four key institutions – business, government, NGOs and media.

More than 50% of the U.S. general population believe our government system is failing, according to Kety Esquivel, a senior vice president at Edelman. She shared results from the 2017 Edelman Trust Barometer (view results here) that showed a broad decline in trust by the general public across government, business, media and NGOs. From the study, government is the least trusted institution in half of the 28 countries surveyed. Data from the Pew Research Center show similar trends of near historic lows in public trust of government (view results here).

#3CMAAnnual: “When folks are in a fearful state, it’s much more difficult to get messages through to them with communications.” –Kety Esquivel

While misinformation is an honest mistake, disinformation is an intentional falsification (fake news). By the way, the First Amendment protects Fake News.

How do we manage the struggle between misinformation versus disinformation? Media literacy among the public is one way, and holding journalists accountable is another. Public communicators also have a responsibility to provide clear, understandable and accurate information about their governments.

Xavier Higgs, journalist and past president of the National Association of Black Journalists (Los Angeles), challenged the group. Thanks, just the facts please.

“The more precise the information, the better off the public will be – and, as an advocate of the general public, it’s your responsibility as a PIO to provide the facts. You are the expert, I am not. I collate information and disseminate that. My expert witness is you.”

Yet, this is not always what occurs, from his account: “There’s a game we all have to play. There are things you can’t tell me, and there are things I want to know that you feel cannot be released.”

#3CMAAnnual: “The role of civic communicators: to rebuild trust in democracy. The power of delivering reliable info.” (Rick Cole)

We as public communicators believe that an informed public is critical to the functioning of democracy. We also recognize that public information can be manipulated today. One of the most toxic effects of misinformation is to encourage distrust and apathy. How can we ensure that the public information (and invitations to engage) – in many new forms we create – is relevant, objective and impartial? I hope we continue to ask this.

It was an excellent conference – with more strategy, soul searching and commitment to listening. While acknowledging the challenges of a cluttered media landscape, public mistrust and outdated structures, we also shared new resources and tactics to make real connections between people and government.

I nearly forgot. Facebook was there too! With so much breaking news about Facebook and government this week, I’ll save the most irritating Facebook concern among public communicators – for another post!

Interested in more? Check out my last post about the loss of many local newspapers, which can be part of the problem of news reporting and trust regarding local matters. (View post here)

One Response to “How Can Local Government Earn Trust in the Era of Fake News?”

  1. John Stephens

    Catherine – picking up on one part of your post:
    How do we manage the struggle between misinformation versus disinformation? Media literacy among the public is one way….

    My reply: While at first look, most people would respond – that’s a good idea – here’s the challenge. How do you evaluate good sources on media literacy? Using that common online seach tool, I found these four, where there are different flavors of the what and why for media critique and literacy.

    What do you think? Media Literacy education – which teaches students to apply critical thinking to media messages and to use media to create their own messages – is a key 21st century skill.

    Media Research Center – MRC’s sole mission is to expose and neutralize the propaganda arm of the Left: the national news media. Television, print media, the Internet… all are filled with advertising, opinions, and other hidden persuasions. In this BrainPOP movie, Tim and Moby teach you how to be a more astute consumer of mass media.

    Media Matters for America – Media Matters for America is… dedicated to comprehensively monitoring, analyzing, and correcting conservative misinformation in the U.S. media.


Join the Conversation

If you are having problems with commenting please let us know here by creating a ticket.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *