Are we overly focused on social media?

This entry was contributed by on April 26th, 2018 at 9:53 am and is filed under , , , , .
Please note...
This site welcomes a variety of viewpoints and perspectives on community engagement. Ideas shared here should not be considered as being endorsed by the UNC School of Government in any way as the School is nonpartisan and policy-neutral.
Download PDF

Many of us were following the Facebook hearings this April in which nearly 100 members of Congress questioned Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg. The hearings came after news broke that Cambridge Analytica, a data firm with ties to President Donald Trump’s campaign, accessed information from as many as 87 million Facebook users without their knowledge.

While the outrage focused primarily on consumer privacy, it also elevated interest in Facebook’s impact on civil discourse and domestic institutions around the world. We are learning more about the addictive nature and manipulative strategies of Facebook and other social media.

I am looking forward to hearing from Eva Guidarini of Facebook’s government outreach division who may address some of these issues as a presenter at the NC City & County Communicators (NC3C) Annual Conference in New Bern April 18-20.

We’re engaging with people who are addicted to smartphones and social media

When my 19-year-old son Nick (photo) gave up his smartphone last Christmas, he wanted to improve his concentration and mindfulness. Over these few months, he observes that his friends instantly whip out their smartphones when there is an uncomfortable silence and lull in conversation. He notices that people are not always engaging in real life and the moment.

He felt addicted to social media and the smartphone made it all too easy to access it many times a day. He’s not alone. Apparently, about half of Americans openly admit they couldn’t last a day without their smartphone. Read Thomas Goulding’s experience in “How getting rid of my smartphone revolutionized my life” in The Independent.

Are we becoming overly focused on social media for engagement?

Nick’s distinction between real life and social media life hit home with me in the professional arena too. Because I realize that we are increasingly focused on social media as a tool for community engagement.

Getting active on social media made a lot of sense for the Town of Chapel Hill about 10 years ago when we saw it as a great way to reach UNC-Chapel Hill students. Since then we have grown to more than 20K followers on @ChapelHillGov Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. We have been excited to watch the growth of our communication and engagement channels, especially since our local newspaper folded.

And then I gained a new satisfaction – finally, as government communicators we have data to demonstrate results. We have social media analytics – the impressions and engagement data on Twitter, likes and views, reach and reactions on Facebook, and so on. The data tracks our community engagement – on social media, at least.

If I have an addiction, it is in tracking social media analytics. If you check out our communications dashboard, you’ll see what I mean. Credit goes to Mark Losey for creating these each month. But I have to remind myself that this is a small part of our overall engagement with the community.

Reminding myself to stay humble and honest in community relations

I am curious to know how others measure progress for broad and long-term community engagement.

As a local government, we have meetings, lots of them. While we put out information to the public to announce these events, we do not track the engagement that occurs during or after the meetings. Is this a missed opportunity?

While we track the numbers of applicants for advisory boards such as the planning commission and housing advisory board, we do not track the number of registered voters and participation in our local elections. While we ask questions in our biennial Chapel Hill Community Survey to rate satisfaction with “level of public involvement in Town decision making,” more than half of all respondents answered “neutral” or “don’t know.” (27% very satisfied/satisfied; 57% neutral/don’t know and 16% dissatisfied/very dissatisfied).

These questions are a reminder to myself to stay humble and honest about the supposed engagement created on social media platforms. While I value them as part of a portfolio of varied efforts, I will continue to search for richer and more creative forms of community engagement. Where better to look than right here!

One Response to “Are we overly focused on social media?”

  1. Rick Morse

    I really enjoyed your post, Catherine. These are highly relevant questions. And as more folks work to minimize screen time and social media use (in the same way they are trying to make other healthy lifestyle improvements, like sitting less at work or consuming less sugar), I wonder how that will impact social media’s role in terms of civic engagement? I also wonder how we, in our own lives and in our communities can promote more face-time and more real dialogue? Social media has it’s place, but it certainly doesn’t seem to be a great platform for civil exchange or relationship-building.

    Reply

Join the Conversation

If you are having problems with commenting please let us know here by creating a ticket.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *